
By Rod Benson
The justification of beliefs, and the defence of claims to know that something or other is the case, is achieved through various means. The Anglican Richard Hooker (1554-1600) spoke of “three-legged stool” comprising three legs or loci of authority: Scripture, tradition and reason. This was later augmented by the addition of a fourth leg of experience to establish the so-called “Wesleyan quadrilateral.”[1]
But enough about stools. This paper considers how George Henry Morling appealed to experience in verifying truth claims – not merely about the existence of God, but various claims often referred to as religious truths. As a human quality, experience is arguably not alien to the intellect but is characterised by the same blend of cognitive, emotional, rational and motor operations.[2]
Experience may be defined in various ways. Practical theologian Jim Fodor identifies five common contemporary meanings:
- sense experience: seeing, hearing, tasting, touching, smelling;
- validation: the process of distinguishing what we know to be true from what we regard as opinion;
- affective experience: the expression of personal feelings, emotions, desires and overall mood;
- know-how: practical judgment acquired by means of long-practiced familiarity with proven ways of doing things;
- spiritual (or mystical) experience: the notion “that there is some meaningful way in which ‘contact’ with God is possible through [the spiritual] senses.[3]
Examples of this fifth meaning abound in Scripture (e.g. Ps 34:9; Hos 4:1; Mt 5:8; 2 Cor 2:15; 1 Pet 2:3). For Fodor, however, “‘experience’ does not simply name one source of knowledge to which theologians might choose to attend, and which might then need to be related to other sources such as Scripture and tradition. Rather, the practice of Christian theology is experiential through and through.”[4] I suspect Morling might have agreed.
In the field of religious experience, we may distinguish three interrelated levels of meaning:
- phenomenological: examining what appears to the subject;
- psychological: focusing on the psychic processes of the subject;
- ontological: reflecting on the “external reality” referred to by the subject.[5]
For Morling, we are primarily concerned here with the psychological and ontological significance of experiences and their utility for corroborating religious beliefs. A perennial problem in Christian theology, not always addressed by theologians, is that of the reliability of reports of unmediated spiritual experience and the possibility of self-deception on the part of the subject. This is a matter beyond the scope of this paper.
The place of experience in evangelical religion
Church historian John Bollen suggests that “although adult baptism accorded with evangelical spirituality, Australia was not a land of revival and most Australian Christians were content with the foothills of religious experience.”[6] Was Morling so content? How did Morling sense the reality of God? What place did he give to experience in verifying truth claims or in determining the authority or otherwise of religious beliefs? Bollen made the mistake of excising Morling’s contribution from his history of Baptists in Australia (except for noting in endnote 258 that he had done so). While I agree that revival is unlikely in Australia, I am not persuaded by Bollen’s general statement regarding religious experience, and it does not accord with Morling’s aspirations or achievements.
Morling was aware of the distinctive Baptist emphasis on vital spiritual experience. In 1942, speaking at a conference between representatives of Baptist and Churches of Christ leaders on the possibility of denominational union (which he opposed), Morling noted a “similarity of tone or atmosphere in our two fellowships” which he attributed to “an evangelical warmth, which places emphasis on personal religion and inner spiritual experience” (doc 35:1).
Morling often referred to a quality he called “spiritual inwardness” or “the inwardness of the Christian life” (e.g. doc 6:83; doc 44:30), by which he meant a deep inner experiential conviction of the reality of God in Christ, expressed in the indwelling presence of Christ through the Holy Spirit. Prior to the Easter events and Pentecost, the disciples lacked such an experience (Jn 16:7; doc 6:93). Referring to John 14:16f, Morling observes three aspects of the experience of the Holy Spirit in relation to the individual which confirm the reality of God and commend or invite trust on the part of the spiritual seeker: the Spirit may be “an external Presence perceived in another but not known experimentally by ourselves”; or personally experienced in the sense of companionship (“abiding with”); or indwelling, which he considered “the fulness of the Gift,” enabling “the possibility of communion” with God.
Where the gulf between the biblical ideal and lived reality loomed large, Morling emphasised the value of this spiritual inwardness. Commenting on Romans 8:23-25, he quotes Handley Moule (one of his chief references), who identified Paul’s phrase “to groan inwardly” with psychological challenges. He links this description of inner struggle with the promise of glory, almost in the mode of positive thinking, suggesting that the conflicted self may be strengthened and the outlook brightened by a fresh understanding of the certainty of glorification through union with Christ, and the assurance that, here and now, Christ is “the weak one’s power” (doc 44:30).
Religion of the heart
Although evangelicals may often think of their faith in cognitive terms, in practice faith is profoundly an experiential matter, and their religion is “a religion of the heart.”[7] For Morling, it was not only essential that the indicative theological truths of the gospel be embraced and expressed through imperative actions, but that objective spiritual truth be confirmed through subjective experience. Worship precedes witness; “repose” (a characteristic term of Morling’s) is the foundation and fuel of duty and discipleship. Writing in 1948 for his regular column in The Australian Baptist on the Song of Songs, which he typically applied as a spiritual analogy of the relationship between Christ and the church (or Christ and the believer), Morling directly addressed the reader:
Lonely soul, once radiant with joys which are now but a hallowed memory, remember that your Saviour, Divine Lover of your soul, has received you into a heart union which is more real in fact than any union on earth. What is real in fact can also be real in experience (doc 27:3).
The impact of this “heart union” was evident in Paul’s spiritual experience. On Romans 6:17f, for example, Morling quotes Moule:
The Last Adam, like the First, transmits not only legal but vital effects to his member … To men innumerable the discovery of this ancient truth, or the fuller apprehension of it, has been indeed like a beginning of a new life (doc 44:21).
Similarly, commenting on 1 John 2:29, Morling explicitly contrasts “absolute knowledge” (that is, intellectual knowledge) with “the knowledge of experience,” stating that “spiritual experience makes it plain that the only sure evidence of the new birth is the righteous life” (doc 7:169). Experience, in this case moral behaviour approved by Scripture, validates and confirms the claim to regeneration.
Occasionally Morling offers personal illustrations of his passion for “spiritual inwardness” and “heart union” with Christ, which provide an insight into his general outlook and indicates what perhaps most impressed him in relation to key principles and practices. In his book, The Quest for Serenity, published in 1951, Morling quotes an account of Welsh Congregational minister and poet Howell Elvet Lewis (1860-1953), where a member of Lewis’s congregation said to him, “Pastor, my best times with the Lord Jesus are not when I am on my knees in formal prayer: but when I have finished praying and sit in my rocking chair chatting things over with him.” To which Morling added, to the reader, “Do you not think with me that when to simplicity is added such intimacy towards God, a still deeper quiet sinks into the soul?” (doc 46:47). Perhaps unsurprisingly, a religion of the heart flourishes in the presence of a rich relational connection with the divine.
In a 1950 booklet on Bible study, Morling encouraged the reader to contemplate Christ “steadily and thoughtfully and adoringly” in the Gospels, and to “encourage your heart with his invisible power as you read in the Acts the triumphs of the early church” (doc 121:9). That is, he argues, a posture of adoration should accompany intellectual enquiry when engaging as an evangelical Christian with Scripture. In the same document, Morling relates a rare personal experience regarding his reading of the New Testament letters:
I myself testify that I had a new vision of truth when I realised that the Epistles were saturated with Christ and I began to love them with my mind as well as my heart as I studied the deep doctrines of grace (doc 121:9f).
For Morling, devotional Bible reading at its best involved more than intellectual knowledge and volitional assent to the truth of Scripture, and more even than heart-warming emotional response. The practice was a doorway to the experience of mystical communion with the living Christ:
Like John on Patmos [Rev 19:10; cf 1:17], you will fall at the feet of the Lamb in the midst of the Throne as, in the book of Revelation, in anticipation you witness the final victory of Him Who is now the rejected of men. Yes! The student of the Scriptures must certainly find Christ in them (doc 121:10).
Moreover, as one encounters the living Christ through such devotional activity, the heart may be warmed, relationship with Christ strengthened, existential trust confirmed, spiritual assurance clarified, and objective truth verified by way of subjective experience.
The Keswick teaching
We do not know when first contact occurred, but throughout his adult life Morling seems to have embraced the classic holiness or “Higher Life” teaching of the Keswick movement. He was a frequent speaker at the two main Australian centres of Keswick spirituality, at Katoomba Convention in the Blue Mountains and at Belgrave Heights in Melbourne, and also in Auckland where he was occasionally a guest speaker. His frequent visits to India may have involved similar ministry. This is not the place to document Morling’s Keswick credentials or work, but to note the profound Keswick emphasis on spiritual experience and its consistent representation in Morling’s theology over a span of 30 years.
One of the central assumptions of Keswick-style teaching is that there are two or more stages in Christian experience: an initial gift of the Spirit, at regeneration, to all believers; and a subsequent gift of the Spirit to those who seek for it. This was viewed as a new quality of Christian experience distinct from conversion. The doctrine was taught by such leaders as John Wesley, Charles Finney, R.A. Torrey, and Andrew Murray, among others, often (but not always) associated with the doctrine of perfectionism, and was adopted by the early leaders of the Keswick movement.
Morling shared the Keswick view, perhaps because he saw his own Peel River experience at Tamworth in late 1913 or early 1914, prior to commencing formal theological studies, as of the same kind. Here is Morling’s mature recollection of that experience:
In my own life increase of rest has kept pace with deeper insight into the doctrines of grace which minister to the life within. There came a time in young manhood when, although I was a sincere and outwardly loyal disciple, doubts and fears assailed me. Then I ‘walked in darkness and knew no light’; however, I could and did still trust in the name of the Lord and stay upon my God. The dawning of a great light was not far off. The Sunrising from on high soon visited me. I became assured of sonship with God and I have never for a moment wavered in that assurance …
Service was rendered to the Lord Jesus and His Church with an almost intolerable sense of strain. There was a burdensome sensitiveness and a great anxiety about results. Relief came, as through patient study and prayer, enlightenment was given on God’s provisions for a naturally restless heart like mine. As, one by one, the magnificent truths of grace were brought home to me, I made humble heart adjustment to them. There have been no cataclysmic experiences; only a progressively enriched experience.[8]
I am not certain that this experience was equivalent to the experience pursued by the “Higher Life” movement, but there are similarities, notably in the emphasis on coming to a point of post-conversion existential crisis, and on personal spiritual experience breathing spiritual vitality into formal, conceptual Christianity.
In any case, we find Morling in 1932 at the Katoomba Convention, preaching on “The soul’s union with Christ,” expounding Ephesians 2:19-22 and 3:14-17 to an ardent Keswick-style crowd. He states that Christ does not “dwell” in the heart of every believer in the sense intended by Paul in Ephesians 3:17. For Morling, this deep inner spiritual experience is a separate experience from that of regeneration and adoption in the logical order of salvation, and constitutes an aspect of sanctification. In his address Morling confesses to his “experience of past days” (whether this refers to recent days at the Convention or much earlier, perhaps at Peel River or elsewhere, we do not know). The experience, which others too may share, involves
a deep dissatisfaction with the life; there is the realisation that somehow Christ is not at the very centre, not influencing every action, not behind every motive. He is in the life, but not right at the heart. Here is the message then: let the Holy Spirit do His blessed work of strengthening the inner man so that there may be the definite reception of Jesus Christ in this sense by faith … God in Christ wants to possess your life and He knows you are not prepared for His coming, so in His wondrous grace He prepares the way through His Spirit for His own coming … But he wants your cooperation. Give it to Him this afternoon. Are you dissatisfied? Here is the possibility of full satisfaction, Christ dwelling in the heart by faith … Let the Holy Spirit strengthen you to make the reception of faith. Amen (doc 10: 131f).
At the same Convention meetings, Morling expounds Romans 12:1-2 with a Keswick twist, on “true consecration.” This suggests, of course, the possibility of an experience of “false” consecration and the need for discernment. He relates the story of Dwight L. Moody’s (1837-1899) apparently sole visit to the original Keswick Convention, where Moody
spoke about his spiritual experience. He was moved to the depths as he told what Christ had done for him, and with tears streaming down his cheeks he said, “This is my experience. The Lord has said to me, ‘Son, all that I have is thine’ ” (doc 12:181).
“After the experiences of this week,” Morling adds, “we may understand Moody’s emotion” (doc 12:181). Here we have a description of strong emotion, accompanied by testimony to an incontrovertible spiritual experience by a leading evangelical statesman, in confirmation of religious truths. And Morling draws a parallel between the experience of Moody and a shared experience that had apparently occurred several days before at Katoomba. Experience here is employed to validate truth claims as well as to legitimize other experiences which bear a family resemblance to that of Moody.
The Keswick teaching revisited
Thirty years later, Morling stood on the same Katoomba platform and boldly endorsed “Keswick teaching.” He quoted a statement of the mature movement’s contemporary essence, which exemplifies the evangelical search for spiritual experience to validate doctrinal beliefs:
In every part of Christendom the God of all grace has given to many of His children a feeling of deep dissatisfaction with their present spiritual state and a strong conviction that the truths that they believe might and should exercise a power over their hearts and lives altogether beyond anything they have as yet experienced. They have been brought to see that personal holiness is God’s purpose for them as well as His command. They see with deep distress the grievous gap there is between what they know of Scriptural truth and how they live. This is not a reaching out toward new forms of doctrine or of ecclesiastical system, but the felt need of more vitality in what has already been accepted (doc 15:64).
This is the heart of both the Keswick message and Morling’s own emphasis on spiritual experience employed to verify religious truth claims, reaffirm personal faith and prepare for a renewed passion for discipleship. However, Morling knew that over-reliance on experience, and an emphasis on emotion at the expense of sober judgment, could lead to behavioural aberrations and doctrinal heresy. In his undated lecture notes on the person of Christ, he qualifies his apparently strong emphasis on experience:
It is urged in some quarters that Christianity is essentially an experience and that spiritual experience is independent of historic fact. The true position is that the Christian religion is a blending of the historical and the spiritual (doc 59:3).
In the same context he approvingly quotes theologian David W. Forrest and the influential Christian mystic Evelyn Underhill (1875-1941) (doc 59:3).
Conclusion
In 1948, Morling gave another Keswick-style address at Last Upwey (now Belgrave Heights) in Melbourne. In the process of expounding Romans 6:1-14, he took the opportunity to correct an apparent misconstrual of the place of the intellect in the Christian life. His transcribed comment demonstrates the balance for which he was well known, and his passion for the intellectual rigour of good theologizing, matched by a deep personal experience of Christ:
I expect you feel sometimes that you are taxed intellectually by what you hear from this platform; and that is a good thing. The things of God challenge the mind as well as the will. Remember this, dear friends, that when we love God perfectly we love him with the whole life, not only with the feelings, but also with the mind and the will (doc 18:31).
Rev Dr Rod Benson lives in Sydney and writes about a range of topics from books and local history to food, faith, philosophy, ethics, research skills, and everyday life. Away from the keyboard, he enjoys cooking for friends, walking in the Australian bush, exploring a beach, discovering new restaurants, and reading philosophy, fiction and poetry. He is married to Emma and is minister of North Rocks Community Church, a Uniting Church congregation. This paper was presented at a Postgraduate Research Seminar at Morling College on 9 April 2018.
References
Note: references to “doc…” in the text above refer to my own classification of archival documents in preparation for my PhD research on Morling. For full details of these documents please contact me by email.
[1] On experience in theological perspective see Sarah Coakley & P.L. Gavrilyuk, The Spiritual Senses: Perceiving God in Western Christianity (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2012); Oliver D. Crisp, “Faith and experience,” in Gerald R. McDermott (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Evangelical Theology (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010), 68-80; I.H. Marshall (ed.), Christian Experience in Theology and Life: Papers read at the 1984 conference (Edinburgh: Rutherford House Books, 1988); and George P. Scher, S.J., “The appeal to experience,” Theological Studies 53 (1), 1991, 40-59.
[2] William A. Van Roo, “Experience and theology,” Gregorianum 66 (4), 1985, 622.
[3] Jim Fodor, “Experience,” in Mike Higton & Jim Fodor (eds), The Routledge Companion to the Practice of Christian Theology (Abingdon, UK: Routledge, 2015), 299-309.
[4] Fodor, “Experience,” 306.
[5] Fred Berthold, “The meaning of religious experience,” Journal of Religion 32 (4), 1952, 268f.
[6] J.D. Bollen, Australian Baptists Past and Present (Eastwood, NSW: Baptist Historical Society of NSW, 1988), 57f.
[7] Elizabeth Jay, The Religion of the Heart: Anglican Evangelicalism and the Nineteenth-Century Novel (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1979).
[8] G.H. Morling, The Quest for Serenity ((Grand Rapids: Wm B. Eerdmans, 1965 [1951), 28f.
Image source: Alltrails
